Top Responses to “Rob Roy: The value of honor”

Small Andy G Thanks Kristi for your inspiringly thoughtful and honorable review. I watched Rob Roy once again last night where it was shown nationally on cable TV. I wanted to revisit it to compare it with my first viewing and enjoyed it even better than I'd remembered. Extremely well written... More »
Small Kurt K Kirsti, thank you for a wonderful review! I especially enjoyed the way you demonstrated the operation of a consistent theme throughout Rob Roy's story. That particular kind of stylization, which shows that the world is a place of meaning, is just as valuable to me as the... More »
Small John G Excellent perspective on what is probably the best romantic realist movie of cinema history (or at least I can't think of any from the past 100 years that beats this). Given the rich and eloquent script by Sharp, the great direction by Caton-Jones and art direction and... More »

Recently Online

Small Small Small Small Small Small Small Small Small Small Small Small Small Small Small Small

From Our Blog See all »

Les Miserables is magnificent

From Don Hauptman: You can believe the hype: Les Miserables is magnificent. The achievement is especially noteworthy given... More »

First mini-review of the Atlas Shrugged Part 2 movie

Pieced together from Q&A in a thread at IMDB, by someone who saw an advance screening: Bottom Line: Definitely better than the... More »

Recent Comments

I think you nailed it! ;) More »
From the point of view of someone who has read quite a lot of Shakespeare and has been a teacher of Shakespeare, this is a wonderful 'overview' essay on his work. In fact, having read most of the... More »
> "adherents insist on melding their economic logic with callow philosophical and historical braggadocio. " -- Do you think he's right? Is he being unfair? It's not so much an issue of whether or... More »
I look forward to reading "Free Market Revolution" and my dream is that we lived in a rational world of people making decisions based on enlightened self interest. We would have peace and prosperity... More »
Here is his criticism, from the end of the article: * * * Free Market Revolution is often persuasive in its arguments about the nature of capitalism and entrepreneurial life and in its economic... More »